If the season ended today, the American League would have a sub .500 team in the Postseason. Needless to say, there’s no time like the present for the Yankees. With a potential lockout looming, a weak American League, and one of the best rotations in baseball, the Yankees should be going for it. The problem is there isn’t much out there to add.
The offense is elite. The rotation is too.
In May, the Yankees posted a 124 wRC+, best in baseball. They led the majors in ISO, walked at an 11% clip, and scored 127 runs in 25 games. Cody Bellinger has been at 183 wRC+. Ben Rice is forcing his way into the middle of the order. Even Aaron Judge’s cold streak came with a 134 wRC+ and an elite walk rate.
On the mound, Cam Schlittler has the best ERA in baseball and his underlying numbers back it up. Will Warren’s 4.67 ERA is misleading, his xERA sits at 2.83. Gerrit Cole looked like himself in his first two starts back. Once Max Fried returns, this rotation could be a top two or three unit in the game.
Don’t get caught up in adding a starter at the deadline. This group is already good, getting healthier, and has real depth. The problems are elsewhere.
Need #1: Catcher
Austin Wells is one of the best pitch framers in baseball but is costing this team runs at the plate. An 18 wRC+ in May. A 37.9% strikeout rate. His xwOBA of .265 says this is not bad luck. The Yankees know it. The question is what they can do about it.
Not much, honestly. Cal Raleigh, Shea Langeliers, Drake Baldwin, William Contreras, every elite catcher is either on a contender, pre-arb, or both.
Ryan Jeffers is the one realistic name. The Twins may listen. But he’s coming off a hamate injury in his catching hand, which is about the worst possible injury for a catcher. The Yankees would be absorbing that risk on top of the time it takes any catcher to get comfortable with a new pitching staff. That’s a lot to take on. . Christian Vazquez could be someone to keep an eye on as well
Need #2: Third base
Ryan McMahon has been nearly unplayable. An 86 wRC+ is bad. His xwOBA of .303 says it’s not bad luck. He’s been poor defensively too.
The market is bleak: Eugenio Suarez (CIN), Alec Bohm (PHI), Isaac Paredes (HOU), Josh Jung (TEX), Nolan Gorman (STL), Mark Vientos (NYM), Matt Shaw (CHC). These are the names that might be kicked around, but it’ll depend on where there teams stand in the playoff race.
Potentially the most realistic option is Zach McKinstry. He’s better than McMahon, offers positional flexibility, and gives you a left-handed platoon bat. But he is not an impact player. That’s the market.
Need #3: Right-handed outfield
The Yankees could use a right-handed bat to either platoon with Trent Grisham or push Bellinger to center. The top right-handed outfielders are almost all unavailable. Fun fact, Randal Grichuk has a 196 wRC+ as a member of the Chicago White Sox. He had a 43 wRC+ as a New York Yankee before being DFA’d/
Byron Buxton has a no-trade clause and would likely only waive it for Atlanta. Julio Rodríguez is Seattle’s franchise player. Ronald Acuña Jr. is on the best contract in baseball for a first-place team. Jackson Chourio is the face of the Brewers. Wyatt Langford is pre-arb with 4.5 years of control.
Taylor Ward from the Angels is the one semi-realistic name. He’s on a division rival that is still competing, which complicates things. But he’s basically the only name on the board that could do anything for this lineup from the right side.
Need #4: Bullpen
David Bednar has a 4.70 ERA and has allowed a base runner in 18 of 23 appearances. He’s fine. You can trust him to close games in October, but his shakiness leaves some to be desired out of the back-end of the bullpen.
Mason Miller, Cade Smith, and Shane Drohan are all pre-arb and on contenders. Jhoan Duran’s Phillies are competing. The most realistic external name is Lake Bachar from Miami, 31 years old, under control through 2031, 3.04 ERA, 10 strikeouts per nine innings. He’s not a proven closer but the Marlins are sellers and the stuff is real.
Internally, Bradley Hanner has a 1.54 ERA at Triple-A, Eric Reyzelman has been dominant at Double-A, and Carlos Lagrange touched 103 mph in spring training and may be more useful out of the bullpen than in the rotation at this point. We could also see Ryan Weathers shift to the bullpen as the rotation gets crowded.
The one big swing: Tarik Skubal
If Detroit listens and Skubal is healthy, he changes the ceiling on this team. Will Warren and Spencer Jones is a fair starting point. Warren’s xERA of 2.83 is better than his surface numbers, and Jones was not ready in his first call-up. Throwing in Elmer Rodríguez to close a deal would be acceptable.
Lagrange, Lombard, and the core prospects should not move for anyone. The Tigers would almost certainly ask for one of them, so it’s unlikely to say the least.
Bottom line
The Yankees have the best offense in baseball, a rotation that could be elite by October, and a real shot at a title with a potential lockout making next year’s window uncertain. But the trade market is not set up to help them the way fans are hoping. McKinstry at third, Jeffers at catcher if healthy, Bachar in the pen, that’s probably the realistic haul. It’s not glamorous. The core may just have to be good enough. There’s a reasonable case it is.